• About
  • Membership
  • Support
  • Membership / Event portal
  • Email Sign Up
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • GooglePlus
  • Youtube
  • RSS
Menu
  • Publications
      • Our Publications
      • Orbis
      • Current Issue
      • Back Issues
      • Orbis Staff/Masthead
      • Electronic Publications

      • E-Notes
      • E-Books
      • FootNotes
      • View all Publications
      • Our Multimedia
      • Audio, Video, and Other Multimedia

        FPRI periodically makes recordings of lectures, forums, and other events available online in streaming formats and as file downloads.
      • Compulsion in Religion: Saddam Hussein, Islam, and the Roots of Insurgencies
      • China’s Emerging Role in the Asia-Pacific and Beyond
      • The Return of Marco Polo’s World
      • Life After the Caliphate
      • Strait and Narrower?: Beijing’s Flight Paths, Taiwan’s International Space, and Regional Security
      • More
      • Trending
        • China, Russia, ISIS, United States, Japan, al Qaeda, Trump, South China Sea, Syria, iraq, Donald Trump, Islamic State, Turkey, Taiwan, Philippines, Spratly Islands, Putin, Middle East, India, Ukraine, Vladimir Putin, Vietnam, foreign policy, foreign fighters, NATO

      • Departure of Bossert Reveals “Boltonization” of National Security CouncilApril 12, 2018
      • Collective Security without an Alliance: Finland’s Defense Relationship with SwedenApril 5, 2018
      • More
    • Close
  • Research
      • Research Programs

      • Program on National Security
      • Program on the Middle East
      • Center for the Study of America and the West
      • Asia Program
      • Eurasia Program
      • Other FPRI Initiatives
      • Scholars

      • SEARCH BY NAME

      • SEARCH BY PROGRAM

      • VIEW ALL AFFLIATED SCHOLARS

      • Scholars in the News

        • Research Associate Thomas J. Shattuck Quoted by CNBC on U.S.-Taiwan Relations
          Apr, 2018

          Senior Fellow Stephen Kotkin Quoted in the Wall Street Journal on Putin’s Presidency
          Mar, 2018

          Eurasia Program Co-Chair John R. Haines Quoted in Talk Media News on Trump Meeting Kim Jong Un
          Mar, 2018

          • More
    • Close
  • Events
      • Event Series

      • Geopolitics with Granieri
      • Main Line Briefings
      • Princeton Committee of FPRI
      • Sponsors Forum
      • Templeton Lecture on Religion and World Affairs
      • Briefings, Booktalks, and Conversations
      • Conferences and Symposia
        • FPRI in D.C.
      • History Institutes
      • Annual Champagne Brunch for Partners
      • FPRI Annual Dinner
      • Upcoming Events

        • Politics and Policy of East Asia’s Economic Future (DC)

          Thursday, April 19, 2018 - 01:00 PM

          2018 Champagne Brunch for Partners

          Sunday, April 22, 2018 - 12:00 PM

          Stephen Kotkin

      • See the full calendar
      • Event and Lecture Archive

      • Event and Lecture Archive
      • Audio/ Video of Past Events
      • Upcoming Webcast
      • webcast archive
    • Close
  • Education
      • About The Wachman Center

      • Dr. Marvin Wachman (1917-2007) was a great advocate for educating young people. In a distinguished academic career, he served as president of both Temple University and Lincoln University and led the Foreign Policy Research Institute as president from 1983 to 1989. Throughout his life, he remained a passionate believer that “you never stop learning.” Established in 1990, the Wachman Center is dedicated to improving international and civic literacy for high school teachers and high school students.

      • Read More
      • Butcher History Institutes

      • Upcoming Event
        • There are no upcoming events at this time.
      • Teaching Military History
      • Teaching the Middle East
      • Other History Institute Programs
      • Honor Roll of Schools
      • Other Resources

      • FootNotes
      • Civic Education Initiative
      • Intern Corner
      • Lesson Plans for Teachers
      • Webcasts
      • School Membership

      • Audio/Video Archive
      • Past History Institutes
      • Full Event and Lecture Archive
    • Close
  • News
      • BackChannel

      • Announcing the 2017 Annual ReportMarch 26, 2018
      • FPRI Elects New Vice Chairman and Five New TrusteesMarch 6, 2018
      • Announcing Chris Miller’s New Book on PutinomicsMarch 6, 2018
      • Chris Miller to Head FPRI’s Eurasia Program; Maia Otarashvili Named Deputy DirectorFebruary 20, 2018
      • More – Newsletter of the Foreign Policy Research Institute.
      • Other News

      • Research Associate Thomas J. Shattuck Quoted by CNBC on U.S.-Taiwan RelationsApril 10, 2018
      • Announcing the 2017 Annual ReportMarch 26, 2018
      • Senior Fellow Stephen Kotkin Quoted in the Wall Street Journal on Putin’s PresidencyMarch 9, 2018
      • News
      • Press Contact Information
      • For information about FPRI, or to reach one of our scholars for an interview or comment, please contact:

        Natalia Kopytnik
        Communications Coordinator
        (215) 732-3774 ext. 122
        [email protected]
    • Close
  • About
  • Login
  • Membership
  • Support
  • Email Sign Up

The American Review of Books, Blogs, and Bull

Letter from the Editor – Issue 5

Ronald J. Granieri

May 20, 2016

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Ron Granieri is an FPRI Templeton Fellow, the Executive Director of FPRI’s Center for the Study of America and the West, Editor of the Center’s E-publication The American Review of Books, Blogs, and Bull, and Host of Geopolitics with Granieri, a monthly series of events for FPRI Members.Read More

Ronald J. Granieri is Executive Director of FPRI’s Center for the Study of America and the West; Editor of FPRI’s new monthly e-publication The American Review, and host of Geopolitics with Granieri, a monthly discussion program at FPRI. A historian of modern Europe, he received his Ph.D. from the University of Chicago and is currently Director of Research at the Lauder Institute at the University of Pennsylvania.

Related program(s)

Center for the Study of America and the West

American Review Cover Issue 5

Europe and the United States have spent the last few years deeply immersed in the memory of the First World War. Each day, each month, each year brings another centennial to mark and acknowledge—“celebrate” being an inappropriate term in relationship to such a massive human tragedy. Anniversaries provide multiple opportunities for reflection and scholarly reappraisal. FPRI has already marked the centennial of the war’s origins in the Fall 2014 issue of Orbis, which included articles on the war by both Michael Neiberg and John Maurer. FPRI continued the effort with its annual Butcher History Institute, held at the First Division Museum at Cantigny in Wheaton, Illinois, on 9-10 April.

Following a tradition of bringing teachers from across the United States to discuss issues related to American military history, this year’s History Institute chose as its subject the US entry into and participation in the First World War. Hoping to introduce the teachers to some of the newest scholarship on the war as they prepare lesson plans in advance of the 2017 centennial of US entry into the war, FPRI scholars spoke on a wide range of topics over the weekend. The First Division was itself born in the First World War, and its museum is housed at the former estate of legendary Chicago Tribune publisher Col. Robert McCormick, who served with the First and named his estate in the western suburbs of Chicago after the French town where the division experienced its first action in May 1918. The First Division Museum has hosted eleven such history institutes over the years, though this one was especially poignant considering the connection between the topic and the location.

To mark the centennial and celebrate the success of the History Institute, FPRI plans to publish revised versions of the lectures from that lively and stimulating weekend. Walter McDougall’s study of “The Great War’s Impact on American Foreign Policy and Civil Religion,” has already appeared as an FPRI E-Note in April. This month’s issue of The American Review offers three more presentations made to the teachers.

Prof. Michael Neiberg of the Army War College, author of an Dance of the Furies, an influential book on the European response to the coming of the War, spoke about the American public’s reactions to the war, both during the era of neutrality and beyond. His findings, which many will find surprising, preview some of the arguments in his forthcoming book, The Path to War: How the First World War Created Modern America. This brief essay version of Professor Neiberg’s talk should give a flavor of his presentation, and, we hope, spur further interest both in the topic and in Prof. Neiberg’s other works.

Col. Douglas Mastriano of the Army War College also offered a pithy and provocative analysis of American preparations for the war and their effects on the US military performance. His critical observations about the reluctance of political leaders (from President Woodrow Wilson on down) to begin preparations before the crisis forced their hands raises important questions about the connections between military policy and domestic politics. In so many ways, the First World War was the beginning of the transition of the United States from relatively isolated regional power to global actor. Mastriano reminds us that many of the challenges associated with that global role—the tension between presidential rhetoric and the realities of administration, for example—were present from the beginning. His message that may not encourage optimism about our ability to solve them today, but should at least encourage us to continue seeking the proper balance between practical efficiency and the messiness of democratic politics in an unruly world.

Finally, Your Humble Editor offers a version of his lecture to the Institute, which was the final lecture of the weekend. Attempting to link the end of the war to its beginning and course, this essay reflects on the nature of the international system and the search for a proper balance between force and diplomacy. Building to Clausewitz’s famous dictum that war is the continuation of politics by other means, the essay explores the tension between the two, as well as the ironic impact that expanded appeals to public opinion can have on both war- and peacemaking. Things rarely go well when warriors and politicians fail to recognize that force and diplomacy should set limits on each other, and the disappointments of the postwar settlement offer yet another reminder of that sad fact.

With these essays, The American Review again stakes its claim to be a place for discussions of the contested terrain between culture, society, and geopolitics. Let us know how you think things have gone thus far. We thank those of you who have contacted us already. You’ll be hearing from us, and we look forward to hearing from more of you in the future.

Onward!

RJG_Sig

 

 

RJG
[email protected]
@RonaldGranieri

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Foreign Policy Research Institute, founded in 1955, is a non-partisan, non-profit 501(c)(3) organization devoted to bringing the insights of scholarship to bear on the development of policies that advance U.S. national interests. In the tradition of our founder, Ambassador Robert Strausz-Hupé, Philadelphia-based FPRI embraces history and geography to illuminate foreign policy challenges facing the United States. More about FPRI »

  • Publications
  • Research
  • Events
  • Education
  • News
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • GooglePlus
  • Youtube
  • RSS

Foreign Policy Research Institute · 1528 Walnut St., Ste. 610 · Philadelphia, PA 19102Tel: 1.215.732.3774Fax: 1.215.732.4401www.fpri.org

Copyright © 2000–2017. All Rights Reserved.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • FPRI Login